The short answer: there is no best habit tracker, only the best one for the kind of habit you have. If your habit happens at a fixed time every day, any simple checkbox app will do, and Streaks or Loop are good ones. If your habit depends on a chance coming up, such as a conversation, a workout when a free hour appears or a “no” to a drink, you need a tracker that records the chance as well as the result.
I make one of these apps, so read this with that in mind. I have tried to say plainly where another app is the better choice. For a lot of habits, it is.
First, what kind of habit is it?
There are roughly two kinds.
- Scheduled habits happen on a slot. Take the tablet at 8am. Drink water. Floss before bed. The chance always comes, so the only question is whether you did it. A checkbox answers that perfectly.
- Opportunity habits depend on a moment arriving. Start a conversation with someone new. Speak up in the meeting. Go to the gym when a free hour turns up. On a day with no tick, a checkbox cannot tell you whether the chance never came or whether it came and you let it pass. That is the one thing worth knowing.
Decide which kind yours is, then use the table. There is more on the difference in how to track a habit that isn’t daily.
Which tracker suits which habit
| If your habit is… | Look for | Good choices |
|---|---|---|
| Daily, on a fixed slot, on Apple devices | Fast logging, Apple Health, widgets | Streaks |
| Daily, on a fixed slot, on Android, free | No account, no ads, works offline | Loop Habit Tracker |
| Something you will only do if it feels like a game | Points, levels, friends | Habitica |
| One of many, across phone and computer | Sync, a web or desktop app, reports | Habitify |
| A simple yes or no, with honest “skip” days | A quiet, colour-coded log | Way of Life |
| A few times a week, no fixed days | A weekly target, not a daily one | Any app with “times a week” |
| Something that depends on a chance arising | Records the chance and the result | Opportunity Habit (ours) |
| Something you want to see on the fridge | Paper | Our free printable |
| Something you want to analyse yourself | Raw data, your own formulas | Google Sheets or Notion |
Five questions to ask of any habit tracker
1. What happens on a day you don’t do it?
This is the question that decides whether you are still using the app in March. Many apps reset a counter to zero. A reset after 29 good days says that one ordinary Tuesday cancelled a month, and that is the moment a lot of people stop. Look for an app that keeps a rate, a total or a score that moves a little, not one that falls to nothing. Loop’s habit strength score works this way, and so does our action rate. The research is in why habit streaks fail.
2. Can it tell a quiet day from a day you let pass?
For scheduled habits this does not matter. For opportunity habits it is the whole point. In one March week I counted 56 chances to start a conversation and took 27. The week had felt quiet. A checkbox would have shown five blank days and told me nothing.
3. How long does logging take, and where?
The habit happens out in the world, not at your desk. If logging takes more than a few seconds, you will do it later from memory, or not at all. My own spreadsheet died of exactly this. Try logging one habit while you are standing up. If it is awkward, it will not last.
4. What is free, and what happens if you stop paying?
Check three things: how many habits the free version allows, whether your history stays if a subscription lapses, and whether you can export it. A one-off purchase is simpler than a subscription. A subscription that holds your own history hostage is worse than either.
5. Where does your data go?
Does the app need an account? Does it work offline? Does its analytics carry the names of your habits? Habit names can be private. The privacy labels on the App Store and Google Play answer most of this in a minute.
Notes on each app
These are short on purpose. Each app’s store page is the source to trust, because prices and features change.
- Streaks (iPhone, iPad, Apple Watch, Mac). Polished and fast, with deep Apple Health support, sold as a one-off purchase rather than a subscription. Built around consecutive days, as the name says. No Android version. Best for scheduled habits on Apple devices.
- Loop Habit Tracker (Android). Free, open source, no ads, no account and no internet needed. Its habit strength score rises and falls gradually instead of resetting to zero. The best free choice on Android.
- Habitica (iPhone, Android, web). Turns your habits into a role-playing game with a character, gold and quests with friends. The core is free, with an optional subscription. Works well if the game is what keeps you coming back. Some people find the game becomes the habit.
- Habitify (iPhone, Android, Mac, web). A capable all-rounder that syncs across devices, with detailed reports. The free plan allows three habits. Best if you track many habits and want them everywhere.
- Way of Life (iPhone). A quiet log where each day is yes, no or skip, shown in colour. Free to start, with in-app purchases. A good fit if you want to record honestly without pressure.
- Paper. Underrated. Visible, free and satisfying to fill in. The weakness is that you can only log where the sheet is. Our printable habit tracker has two tallies in each box, chances and actions, so it works for opportunity habits too.
- Google Sheets or Notion. Total control and your own formulas. The cost is that you do the data entry, usually in the evening, hours after the moment.
- Opportunity Habit (iPhone, Android). Ours. You log each chance with one slide: right if you took it, left if you let it pass. The headline number is your action rate, actions divided by opportunities, over a real week or month. There is no streak, so nothing resets. It works offline and without an account. It is the wrong choice for purely scheduled habits: if the chance always comes, a checkbox is simpler.
A one-week test before you commit
Install your top two. Track the same two habits in both for seven days. At the end of the week, ask which one you opened without being reminded, and which number told you something you did not already know. Keep that one and delete the other.
Choose on a week of use, not on screenshots.