The short answer: yes, on average. A review of 138 studies with nearly 20,000 people found that monitoring progress towards a goal made people more likely to reach it, and the effect was larger when progress was physically recorded. But feedback can also make performance worse, and a tracker built around a score you can lose is where that tends to happen.
What the research says
| Finding | Study | What it means for a tracker |
|---|---|---|
| Monitoring progress increased goal attainment across 138 studies (d+ = 0.40). The effect was larger when progress was physically recorded or reported to others. | Harkin et al. (2016), Psychological Bulletin | Write it down. Recording beats remembering. |
| Feedback improved performance on average (d = .41), but more than 38% of the effects were negative. Feedback got less effective the more it drew attention to the self. | Kluger & DeNisi (1996), Psychological Bulletin | A number that makes you feel judged can backfire. |
| Habits took a median of 66 days to become automatic, ranging from 18 to 254. Missing a single opportunity did not materially affect the process. | Lally et al. (2010), European Journal of Social Psychology | Expect months, not 21 days. One bad day doesn’t matter. |
Put the three together and the picture is clear. Tracking helps because it shows you what you actually did. It hurts when the number becomes a verdict on you rather than information about the habit.
Why most people stop using a habit tracker
The reset
Most trackers count consecutive days. After 29 good days, one ordinary Tuesday sends the counter back to zero. The research says that one day did not matter to the habit. The app says it cancelled the month. A lot of people give up the habit at exactly that point. More on this in why habit streaks fail.
The blank day
For habits that depend on a chance, a blank day is ambiguous. Did the chance never come, or did you let it pass? The tracker can’t say, so its chart can’t tell you anything you can act on. Over time, a chart you can’t read stops being worth opening.
The admin
The habit happens out in the world. If logging means opening a spreadsheet, it moves to the evening, then to the weekend, then it stops. My own spreadsheet ended this way.
The guilt
Opening the app starts to feel like an inspection. Researchers call the response the ostrich problem: people avoid checking on the goals they care about when the answer might be unflattering (Sheeran & Webb, 2016). A tracker that only records successes makes that easy, because a blank feels safer than a written “let it pass”. See habit tracking without shame.
How to track habits so it keeps working
- Record it in the moment, in a few seconds. If it takes longer, you will do it from memory later, and memory flatters.
- Count the chance as well as the action for any habit that depends on a moment arriving. Your number becomes a rate, chances taken divided by chances had, and that rate can tell a quiet week from a week you let things pass.
- Use a number that survives a bad day. A rate or a total moves a point or two after one off day. A counter falls to zero.
- Review weekly, not daily. A day is too small to mean anything. A week, or better a month, shows the pattern. See review the week, not the habit.
- Keep it to three habits until logging them costs you nothing.
- Give it two months. The median in the research was 66 days. If it still feels mechanical at week three, that is normal. See habit tracking feels mechanical.
Tracking works when it is a record, not a verdict.
When a habit tracker is the wrong tool
If the habit is fully automatic already, tracking it adds work and nothing else. If counting makes you anxious rather than curious, stop for a while and just notice instead. And if you enjoy the pressure of a run of days and it is working for you, keep it. This page is not trying to talk you out of something that works.
What I built, and why
I built Opportunity Habit after my own spreadsheet showed me two things. In one March week I had 56 chances to start a conversation, and I took 27. And my starting rate across all my habits was about 20 per cent. A checkbox would have shown neither. The app records each chance with one slide, right if you took it, left if you let it pass, and shows the rate for the week and the month. There is no streak, so nothing resets. The full story is here.
Harkin et al. (2016), Does monitoring goal progress promote goal attainment? A meta-analysis of the experimental evidence, Psychological Bulletin 142(2), 198–229. Kluger & DeNisi (1996), The effects of feedback interventions on performance, Psychological Bulletin 119(2), 254–284. Lally, van Jaarsveld, Potts & Wardle (2010), How are habits formed: Modelling habit formation in the real world, European Journal of Social Psychology 40(6), 998–1009. Sheeran & Webb (2016), The intention–behavior gap, Social and Personality Psychology Compass 10(9), 503–518. None of these studies tested a habit app.